| 2020 |
No voting for Father of the Year in 2020 |
| 2019 |
No voting for Father of the Year in 2019 |
| 2018 |
No voting for Father of the Year in 2018 |
| 2017 |
No voting for Father of the Year in 2017 |
| 2016 |
Joe LeBlanc |
| 2015 |
Adam Elias |
| 2014 |
Scott Borowski |
| 2013 |
Jim Mitterando |
| 2012 |
Ronald Cervone |
| 2011 |
Billy John Mitterando |
| 2010 |
Rich Mitterando |
| 2009 |
John Vingara |
| 2008 |
Skip La Rocca and Michael Ratigan |
| 2007 |
Billy Mitterando |
| 2006 |
Howard Berg |
| 2005 |
Richard Cervone |
| 2004 |
Frankie Dammeyer |
| 2003 |
Anthony Pelliccia |
| 2002 |
Charlie Hydo |
| 2001 |
Tom Davison |
| 2000 |
Jodee Cervone |
| 1999 |
Larry Blauvelt |
| 1998 |
Robbie Mitterando |
| 1997 |
Kevin Coco |
| 1996 |
Michael Cervone and Craig Monteforte |
| 1995 |
Bill James |
| 1994 |
Joe Borawski |
| 1993 |
Louis Mitterando |
| 1992 |
Ernie Monaco |
| 1991 |
Ronnie Cervone |
| 1990 |
Jimmy Mitterando |
| 1989 |
Richie Mitterando |
| 1988 |
Bobby Mitterando |
| 1987 |
Johnny Mitterando |
| 1986 |
Bill Mitterando and Al LaRocca |
| 1985 |
Pep Cervone |
| 1984 |
Bill Ingenito |
| 1983 |
John (Nap) Napurano |
